08 September 2009

Thoughts on Gardening and Bird Feeding

In my line of work, I get a lot of questions about managing "pest species" - squirrels, rabbits, deer, "blackbirds" (including grackles and starlings), house sparrows, and insects.  There are a lot of items on the market claiming to help you keep these animals out of your gardens and feeders.  Some work better than others, and some don't work at all.  Battling these undesirables can be extremely frustrating.  In Second Nature: A Gardener's Education, Michael Pollan tells of his escalating battle to keep a local woodchuck out of his own garden - ending with him pouring gasoline into the woodchuck's burrow and throwing in a match.

Luckily, the woodchuck wasn't home at the time. But there are some interesting ways to try and manage these so-called pests.  Earlier this morning I was reading an article about the pesticide Bacillus thuringiensis (or Bt for short).  Bt is "regarded as environmentally friendly, with little or no effect on humans, wildlife, pollinators, and most other beneficial insects."  Touted as the answer to all your caterpillar problems, it works by causing the caterpillar's gut to essentially swell shut, and the caterpillar starves to death a few days later.  Because it targets a specific group of insects, it is definitely preferred over broad-spectrum pesticides.  However, it will kill all species within that group (e.g. all moths and butterflies).  If you want any butterflies at all in your garden, you shouldn't use Bt.
This is a good example of how a balance must be found.  In my own garden and with my bird feeders, I tend to live and let live (and incidentally I don't use Bt - I personally don't like the idea of intentionally starving an animal to death, caterpillar or otherwise).  I have several feeders spaced out so when the grackles or house sparrows are monopolizing a feeder, the other birds still have a feeder (or feeders) to go to.  I use a suet feeder that can only be accessed from the bottom - woodpeckers and nuthatches have strong enough feet to hang and feed, but other birds cannot.  In my garden, I use companion plantings to keep the insect pests at bay.  Fencing and netting can be used to keep the mammals out.  But I think the biggest control is mindset.  I expect to lose a few vegetables each year.  The animals aren't doing it intentionally; the fruit and vegetable plants we grow taste just as good to them.  And it's actually fun to watch the squirrel acrobatically eating out of my sunflower feeder.  He (or she)'s not there all day long - the birds can still eat out of the feeder after he's done.

No comments: